Nixon’s Gamble: Ray Locker
Peter Schultz
Here is a good summary, in his own words, of Ray Locker’s assessment of Richard Nixon and his presidency:
“Few presidents had accomplished so much. Few accumulated so many enemies. Nixon’s gamble was that he tried to do it all in secret before the weight of the secrets crushed him. That he succeeded at the first part is to his everlasting credit. That he failed to avoid the inevitable collapse is to his everlasting shame.
“The results of his policies are there for all to see. China is now the world’s second-largest economy and the United States’ largest creditor. The arms race between the United States and the Soviet Union slowed, which helped speed up the ultimate collapse of the Soviet Union. Vietnam is now a US ally and rival of China. These all could have happened without Nixon, but hardly as rapidly as he accomplished them.” [288]
While Locker assumes Nixon deserved the enmity of his enemies, questions necessarily arise. Did he deserve that enmity, given his accomplishments? What was it about those accomplishments that did not satisfy, in fact that fed the enmity of his enemies, like Al Haig and the Washington Post? That Nixon was a “bitter, vindictive, and paranoid man [with] a chip on his shoulder each day he entered the Oval Office” was true, as illustrated by Bob Haldeman’s diary. But as Machiavelli wrote about Hannibal, that his “inhuman cruelty” underlay his greatness, so too perhaps Nixon’s flaws, his bitterness, his vindictiveness, his alleged paranoia [you are not paranoid if in fact people are out to get you] underlay and help explain his ability to accomplish so much so quickly. As Machiavelli also wrote: in order to succeed politically, people need “to learn to be able not to be good,” especially among so many who are not good.
Certainly, Nixon knew how “not to be good,” but perhaps he did not understand how important not being good was to succeed politically. And so, as evidenced by his failure to destroy his tapes, e.g., he often tried to be good. He claimed in his farewell remarks that if you hate those who hate you, you destroy yourself. That is a nice, good, almost a “Hallmark” thought. But maybe it is not true. After all, those who hated Nixon did not destroy themselves. In fact, they succeeded. So maybe you destroy yourself when you do not hate those who hate you, because hating is more powerful than not hating. Had Nixon actually accepted his hatred of his enemies as legitimate, he would have been better able to defend himself and his accomplishments.
In the political arena, being good is often not a recipe for success, certainly not among so many who are not good. And as Locker points out, Nixon had many enemies who wanted him to and actively worked to have him fail. His bitterness, his vindictiveness were his weapons, so to speak, aimed at those enemies who did hate him. Those flaws defended and motivated him and underlay his great accomplishments. Richard Nixon deserved to be better thought of, including by himself.
No comments:
Post a Comment