Nixon’s Gamble: Email Exchange
Peter Schultz and Matthew B.
On Sun, Nov 15, 2026 at 6:16 PM Peter Schultz <lpkschultz@gmail.com> wrote:
http://www.anti-federalism.com/2026/11/nixons-gamble-ray-locker.html
Dear Peter,
I wonder, can you explain the three sentences below?
So maybe you destroy yourself when you do not hate
those who hate you, because hating is more powerful than not hating...
Had Nixon actually accepted his hatred of his enemies as legitimate, he would
have been better able to defend himself and his accomplishments...
Richard Nixon deserved to be better thought of, including by himself (http://www.anti-federalism.com/2026/11/nixons-gamble-ray-locker.html).
Peter Schultz’s response: Nov. 16, 2026, 1:55pm:
Why did Nixon’s enemies who hated him succeed if hating your enemies destroys yourself? That if you hate your enemies, you destroy yourself is a really nice, Hallmark-like sentiment, saying it is not good to hate others, who by the way hate you. And additionally perhaps it is safer - not better - to hate those who hate you because hating is much more powerful than not hating.
Remember, Machiavelli asked the question, Is it better to be loved than feared? His answer was that it is safer to be feared than loved, because loving requires a reciprocity. The lover’s success requires something in return, something freely given or withheld, something that can’t be guaranteed, whereas the fearful one’s success does not depend on such reciprocity. Fear compels compliance, whereas love does not. Being feared is more powerful and therefore safer than being loved, although being loved is better.
Hating might not be better than not hating, but it is more powerful and, therefore, more likely to lead to success. By hating his enemies, by accepting his bitterness and vindictiveness as legitimate, Nixon would have been more powerful and, therefore, more likely to succeed. After all his enemies did hate him and sought to destroy him. He wasn’t wrong about that. Are we obligated not to hate those who hate us and seek to destroy us? Are we obligated to turn the other cheek, as it were? If you do that with those who hate you and are not good, be prepared to be abused and destroyed. Jesus turned the other cheek, and he ended up on the cross. Charles Schultz: "If you live like Jesus expect to be crucified."
Nixon didn’t think well enough of himself because he bought into society’s moralizing critique of vindictiveness, bitterness, and hate, which Locker buys into as well. Locker didn’t question whether Nixon deserved the enmity his enemies heaped upon him. He just assumed it was deserved because of Nixon’s “flaws"… and so did Nixon himself as evidenced by his confession in his farewell remarks of his sin of hating his enemies. Didn’t they deserve his hatred? Hadn’t they earned that hatred? Locker, et. al., doesn’t wonder about that.
Well, just as Hannibal’s inhuman cruelty was the basis of his greatness, so too Nixon’s bitterness, vindictiveness, and hatred - which he confessed to as if it were his sin - were the “flaws” that led to his great accomplishments. His vindictiveness, bitterness, and hatred empowered him, were his “weapons,” and led to his remarkable accomplishments. Didn’t those flaws also contribute to Ulysses Grant’s and Sherman’s accomplishments? Do you sense any bitterness, vindictiveness, even hatred in the comedy, e.g., of George Carlin, Richard Pryor, Robin Williams, Dave Chappelle, Louis C.K., and other comedians? Do you detect any bitterness in Jane Austen, say toward the British “aristocracy,” its patriarchy? Another Charles Schultz quote: “If a person goes through life and doesn’t get angry, that person doesn’t know what’s going on.” If a person goes through life and doesn’t experience bitterness, vindictiveness, and, yes, hatred, that person doesn’t know what’s going on.
So it goes.
On Nov 16, 2026, at 7:42 AM, Matthew Brennan <shitlpkschultzsays@gmail.com> wrote:
Peter,
With love, with patience, and with faith, in friendship, I am,
Matthew.
No comments:
Post a Comment