Madison’s Genius: Ambition Counteracting Ambition
Peter Schultz
Regarding Watergate, it is worthwhile to ask why did Nixon eagerly
engage in a cover up of the burglary he had nothing to do with? It was because
he was a narcissist and his cover-up, of successful, was a way of demonstrating
how powerful he was. And I believe that’s what makes coverups and conspiracies
so appealing in the political arena and why they were so widely engaged in
during the Watergate “scandal” by the likes of Al Haig, John Dean, Richard
Helms, James McCord, Howard Hunt, and others.
If Nixon could successfully covering up the burglary, which he thought was “preposterous
and senseless,” he would demonstrate his power, just as he had demonstrated his
power by successfully conspiring to arrange his opening to China and the SALT
agreements he made with the Soviets. Narcissists are first and foremost
interested in demonstrating their power, and not, alternatively, their justice
or humanity.
But suppose Nixon had sought justice in response to the burglary, that is, with
finding out who was responsible and dealing with them appropriately. Such a
course of action would not, probably could not lead to Nixon’s downfall. As
a mentor of mine once said: Nixon should have seriously investigated the burglary,
discovered the culprits and fired them, thereby putting himself at the head of
a reform agenda. But because Nixon was a
narcissist, he was driven to engage in a cover up, using such a conspiracy to
demonstrate his power. The downside to his cover up was that its left him
vulnerable to other narcissists seeking to demonstrate their power by exposing
his cover up and, thereby, bringing him down.
So, as prescribed by James Madison, the separation of powers allowed the ambitious
to counteract the ambitious. Or, in other words, narcissists counteracted
narcissists. As a kind of politics, we are entitled to ask: What could go wrong?
No comments:
Post a Comment